Are Lawsuit Settlements Taxable? The IRS Rules Every U.S. Plaintiff Must Know

Understanding whether a lawsuit settlement is taxable is crucial for any plaintiff navigating the legal system in the United States. The IRS (Internal Revenue Service) has clear but nuanced rules regarding which parts of a settlement are subject to federal income tax. With billions paid out annually in legal settlements, not knowing the tax implications could result in unexpected liability—or missed opportunities for tax planning.

This guide provides a comprehensive breakdown of IRS tax rules on lawsuit settlements, how different types of damages are treated, and what plaintiffs should be aware of before cashing their check.

Understanding the IRS Perspective on Settlements

The Internal Revenue Code (IRC) distinguishes between different categories of legal damages and treats each with unique tax implications. Whether a settlement is taxable depends on why the lawsuit was filed and how the damages are classified.

IRS Publication 4345, titled "Settlements – Taxability", lays out the general rule:

“All income is taxable from whatever source derived, unless it is specifically excluded by law.”

Thus, most settlement amounts are taxable, unless a specific exemption applies.

Taxable vs. Nontaxable Settlements: A Breakdown

1. Physical Injury or Physical Sickness

Nontaxable:
If you receive a settlement for physical injuries or physical sickness, the amount is generally not taxable, as long as:

• You didn’t take an itemized deduction for related medical expenses in prior years.

• The injury or illness is physical in nature (e.g., a broken leg, illness from exposure).

Taxable:
However, if you previously deducted related medical expenses (via Schedule A) and later receive a settlement for those same injuries, that portion becomes taxable under the tax benefit rule.

Example: You sued for injuries from a car accident. The awarded settlement includes medical expenses and pain and suffering related to those injuries—this is not taxable.

2. Emotional Distress or Mental Anguish

Partially Taxable:
Damages for emotional distress are taxable unless they originate from a physical injury or sickness.

• If emotional distress stems from workplace harassment (no physical injury), it’s taxable.

• If it’s directly tied to physical injury (e.g., PTSD from a car crash), it may be excludable.

However, medical expenses paid for emotional distress (like therapy) may be non-taxable if documented and not previously deducted.

3. Lost Wages or Lost Profits

Always Taxable:
Settlements awarded for lost income—such as wages, business income, or contract profits—are fully taxable. The IRS treats this as though you earned the income as usual.

Example: A wrongful termination case awards you $80,000 for lost wages. That amount is subject to ordinary income tax and payroll taxes (Social Security, Medicare).

4. Punitive Damages

Always Taxable:
Punitive damages are intended to punish the defendant, not compensate you. Thus, they are always included in your gross income, even if they relate to a physical injury.

5. Interest on Settlements

Always Taxable:
If the court adds pre-judgment or post-judgment interest to your award, this interest is 100% taxable as ordinary income.

6. Attorney's Fees

This is where plaintiffs often get caught off guard.

• Personal lawsuits (e.g., defamation, emotional distress without physical harm): You’re taxed on the entire settlement, including the portion your attorney takes—even if you only pocket 60%.

• Exceptions: In certain whistleblower, employment, or civil rights cases under IRC §62(a)(20), attorney’s fees may be deductible "above the line."

Pro Tip: To avoid double-taxation, ensure your award breakdown specifies “attorney's fees paid separately” where possible.

Allocation Matters: How Settlements Are Labeled

The IRS respects the allocation of damages as specified in the settlement agreement—unless it appears artificial or manipulated. This means it's wise to negotiate and document the categorization of each component:

• How much is for physical injury?

• How much for emotional distress?

• What portion is attorney’s fees?

• Is any portion allocated to punitive damages or interest?

How to Report Settlements on Your Taxes

Depending on the nature of the settlement, you’ll report the amount on Form 1040 in various sections:

• Line 1 (Wages): For back pay, wrongful termination, etc.

• Schedule 1 (Other income): For emotional distress, punitive damages, etc.

• Schedule C or E: For business-related lawsuits or property damages.

You may also receive a Form 1099-MISC if you received a taxable settlement over $600.

Special Cases and Exceptions

1. Employment Lawsuits

Often include components for lost wages, emotional distress, and attorney’s fees. Carefully allocate categories and ensure proper tax reporting.

2. Whistleblower Lawsuits

These may involve complex federal rules. The IRS Whistleblower Office provides guidance, and certain whistleblower awards under IRC §7623 are taxable but may offer deductions.

3. Wrongful Death Settlements

Vary by state. Some state laws classify wrongful death damages as exempt from taxation. The IRS typically honors these state law classifications.

What Plaintiffs Must Do Before Signing a Settlement Agreement

✅ Consult a Tax Professional Early

Tax consequences should be considered before the settlement is finalized. Consulting with a CPA or tax attorney helps structure settlements efficiently.

✅ Structure the Settlement Wisely

If multiple damage types are involved, itemize the settlement in the agreement. A lump sum with no breakdown gives the IRS full power to decide the taxability.

✅ Use Special Provisions for Legal Fee Deductions

Ask your lawyer if the case qualifies under above-the-line deduction rules, especially for whistleblower or employment cases.

Pros and Cons of Structured Settlements for Tax Efficiency

Final Words

Settlements can be a financial lifeline—but without proper planning, they can also trigger unexpected tax consequences. Whether you're dealing with compensation for a car accident, workplace discrimination, or a business dispute, it’s essential to understand how the IRS classifies lawsuit settlements.

Work closely with legal and tax professionals, structure your agreements with care, and ensure all parties understand the IRS rules that govern your settlement.

Remember: When in doubt, always defer to IRS documentation and qualified tax advisors.

Brand mention:
This informational guide on lawsuit settlement taxation is proudly brought to you by Uorni, your trusted resource for expert legal and financial insights.